Nice photo, but I would have been inclined to crop out the tree that stick out on the left side. Of what I see on the horizon, it appears straight, which is a minor detail but some people miss it and it can sometimes make a photo look strange. Any photo involving water especially should be straight - the good thing is, you got it spot on
I would try and re-border it though, so that the 4 edges were of the same thickness. If you had trouble with that, I'm sure there are bordering tools about that could do the job fdor you. The white on the border works well though
Nice capture at a beautiful spot
Nice picture. Looks like ^hesitation didn't take a close look at this one: she seems to think it's a straight up photo of a lake. That's PS 101, employed to full effectiveness. Looks like you have a promising career ahead of you!
Just one, very significant, image recreating filter, which I would say qualifies it as a manipulation, because the effect is manipulated, not naturally found. Category determined by effect, not quantity is I guess what I mean. Anyway, the joke's on her for not bothering to take a close look. She's also made typos in her DD selection descriptions. Sloppy work, I say.